It’s a condition called hipsteritis, and unfortunately it’s terminal.

I do get you though. I’m not as extreme as what you’re describing, but I’ve definitely had this reaction to some things.

For me, one version of this is sort of an overcorrection to unreasonable expectations. If something is super popular and a bunch of people recommend it to me, I’d expect it to be the best thing ever and… that’s just not how that works. The most popular things are the things that are acceptable to the most people, not necessarily the best or what would be your favorite, so I go see the thing and if it’s just ok I feel like I have to push back against everyone overly praising it.